Why is Apple Intelligence so bad compared to Siri

I was okay with Apple Intelligence if it was just a rebrand of Siri or didn’t have all the features yet. But it’s actually worse. I used Siri a lot—whether I was driving, had my hands full, or just didn’t feel like typing long messages. It used to work decently, but now Apple Intelligence is just frustrating.

It often misses parts of my sentence, like the start or the middle. For example, I might say, “Guess what I just found,” and it misses the beginning, or “I’m so tired of this stupid AI,” and it cuts out the middle part.

When I send longer messages, it seems to forget how punctuation works. It ends up with sentences like, “It structures longer messages. Like it’s never heard of a comma. Before.”

It also messes up simple words. Once, I said “bar graphs,” and it thought I said “bananas.” Impressive, right?

Sometimes it erases my message while I’m trying to confirm if I want to send it. Other times, it just freezes and stops responding entirely. I’ll say, “Hey Siri,” but it’s unresponsive until I restart my phone.

Weirdly, it gets worse if I sound frustrated. If I say, “No, edit,” it either breaks down or makes the message worse than before.

It’s shocking how bad this feature is, even compared to other rushed AI releases.

Apple Intelligence really isn’t great. If you want something that works well, check out the Google Pixel 9 Pro. I’m an Apple user myself—I have the iPhone 16 Pro and use all the beta updates—but Apple Intelligence just doesn’t work like they hyped it up to. I also use a Google Pixel, and their Gemini AI is so much better. The only downside is I’m tied to Apple’s ecosystem.

@Harlan
I think Apple Intelligence was meant to launch fully with iOS 19, but they rushed it out early to please investors.

There’s also talk about iOS 19 introducing a new AI-based Siri, which makes me think they split the release into two phases. But it backfires because now everyone sees the new design but still deals with the same bad Siri. By the time they release the improvements, people might have already moved on.

@Dru
I wonder what iOS 19 will actually bring. They need to update their image editing tool because Image Playground is just terrible.

Emory said:
@Dru
I wonder what iOS 19 will actually bring. They need to update their image editing tool because Image Playground is just terrible.

Why is that even part of the OS? It’s just a gimmick for making low-quality AI images.

Emory said:
@Dru
I wonder what iOS 19 will actually bring. They need to update their image editing tool because Image Playground is just terrible.

‘Need’ is a strong word.

Ira said:

Emory said:
@Dru
I wonder what iOS 19 will actually bring. They need to update their image editing tool because Image Playground is just terrible.

‘Need’ is a strong word.

Fair, but if they’re going to give us these tools, they should at least work properly, right?

@Dru
I doubt anything will change. Apple has lost credibility when it comes to improving Siri or AI features. They messed up big time. Most people don’t care, though. Personally, I’m done.

Skyler said:
@Dru
I doubt anything will change. Apple has lost credibility when it comes to improving Siri or AI features. They messed up big time. Most people don’t care, though. Personally, I’m done.

It’s disappointing because AI assistants have so much potential to be like personal helpers, which is what they promised years ago. But the ones we have now are so bad, and I worry that if people lose interest, we’ll never see the good versions.

@Harlan
Does Gemini process everything on the device, or does it rely on servers? If it’s the latter, that might explain why it’s better.

Wynn said:
@Harlan
Does Gemini process everything on the device, or does it rely on servers? If it’s the latter, that might explain why it’s better.

I’m not sure. I assume it uses servers. Either way, it’s definitely ahead.

@Harlan
That makes sense. Apple’s decision to process more on-device limits what their AI can do. It’s a trade-off, but maybe not worth it.

Wynn said:
@Harlan
Does Gemini process everything on the device, or does it rely on servers? If it’s the latter, that might explain why it’s better.

Didn’t Apple just settle a case about Siri spying? This excuse of ‘on-device processing’ doesn’t hold up anymore.

@Jordy
Siri isn’t fully on-device and never claimed to be, except for small tasks like setting timers in recent versions. You might be confusing data processing with using private data.